The Presidential Beatdown: Round 1

The Presidential Beatdown: Round 1
Part 2 of 7   |   1  2  3  4  5  6  7
Apr. 16, 2010
Recently, there was some big college sports event that everyone was talking about. Basket bowling I think it's called? It's the NCAA or NAACP or something, I dunno.

From game-watching parties to office pools, nearly everyone is having fun getting in on the action. It's like a mini-Superbowl, although clearly not as good because basketball is boring as shit. The thing is, for those of us who couldn't give less of a crap about sports (eg: nerds), we totally miss out on all the fun of setting up brackets and making meticulous probability decisions on your team picks.

And nerds love that stuff!

So this is for you. A bracket tournament with a nerdy historical twist. Last week, we trimmed down our list of participants to 32 and set up our brackets. Let's take a look at those brackets again.

Click to enlarge.


Since the first round consists of 16 separate matches, we're gonna split it up into two weeks. Today's set will include the gentlemen on the left. Participants have been arranged in no specific order, so we'll see some interesting generational leaps in matches, like Bill Clinton vs. Thomas Jefferson.

Let's not waste any more time and just jump right in!


Match #1: John F. Kennedy vs. George W. Bush

Right from the get go, we have an extremely strong, but controversial match-up. JFK, of course, is one of the most beloved Presidents of all time whereas Bush is hated by the entire world. It's Democrat vs. Republican, a man who was assassinated vs. a guy who was almost killed by a pretzel.

That assassination is really what's gonna make this match a quick one. However hated Bush may be, he did serve a full two terms. JFK was killed after only two years in office. So according to rule #7, Bush pretty much gets free reign for six minutes. And Bush was in great physical shape during his Presidency. Mental shape, not so much, but physically he was at the top of his game. Hell, he spent more time at his ranch than the White House. The dude was active.

So for the second time, John will fall victim to the Kennedy Curse.

Winner:



Match #2: Benjamin Harrison vs. William Howard Taft

Benjamin Harrison is clearly the underdog of this entire competition. He only served one term, putting him at a disadvantage against a majority of the other participants, but god dammit if he isn't adorable. You just can't help but root for the guy. He was also relatively short, coming in at only 5'6." But as the old saying goes, it's not the size that counts, it's how well you use it to pleasure a woman. I'm not exactly sure what that has to do with one's stature in a fight, but it sounds fitting.

Taft also only served one term, so "Little Ben," as the Democrats referred to him, is on equal grounds time-wise. The match now comes down to pure physical prowess. Taft was a larger man, overweight by today's standards. He's often described as "jovial," which the New Oxford American Dictionary describes as:
  1. Endowed with or characterized by a hearty, joyous humor or a spirit of good-fellowship.
  2. Fat.
As such, Taft could probably pack one hell of a punch, but would tire easily. This is where Harrison's stature gives him a great advantage. Ben's a small target. He's also quick. Combine those with Taft's inability to last very long and Harrison would quite literally run around him in circles. Not incredibly interesting to watch, but with all those dudes hanging from the sides of the Thunderdome, there's sure to be some great name calling.

Winner:

Share the love!
or
64 Comments
You must be logged in to comment.
 
TheBiffledon  [2 posts]
5 months ago
damn I was hopin Taft's fatness would carry him to the Final Four. I was only 4/8 in this round.

 
 
McThulhu  [2 posts]
5 months ago
Reagan has a two minute head start AND takes a bullet to the chest and keeps on ticking. Bill's probably eliminated in that fight.

Obama vs. Johnson... hmm... Johnson was kind of a bad-ass. Plus, Obama's only been in for one year now, so he's got a HUGE disadvantage. Sucks to be him.

And the ford v. carter fight is just too pathetic to pick. If anything, Carter wins, if only because of the time advantage.

 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Obama is black... no one beats against a black guy in a boxing match...
im all for Lincoln to win, cos of this - http://rogerjnorton.com/Lincoln48.html
lincoln kicked ass in a wrestling match and cmon "Lincoln was 6' 4" and weighed 185 pounds"

 
 
LaureoTheOreo  [5 posts]
5 months ago
BAHAHA this is brilliant Matt! Being British, it has also taught me some interesting facts about some of the U.S. Presidents, which I shall use to my advantage against.... Well not a lot considering I don't study anything to do with American Presidents or have any American friends to impress, or... have any friends... :(

 
jroberts2010  [98 posts]
5 months ago
So...you don't have any friends because you're British, or because you don't study anything to do with America? Just curious

 
Anonymous
5 months ago
must be because your british

 
 
DrewRodriguez20  [5 posts]
5 months ago
Dammit, My left side just got boned 3/8. Dubya or teddy better go all the way

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I'm putting my money on Teddy.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I got Andrew Jackson winning it all, he was one crazy mother fucker, he conquered florida even though he was told not to, he was the hero of New Orleans, plus he took a sword to the face. Not to mention in a duel he got shot then proceded to shoot and kill his opponent

 
 
moss1873  [4 posts]
5 months ago
I went 6/8. not bad, but Wilson and Taft killed me.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
REAGAN SMASH

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Shouldn't Truman have won by dropping the Atomic Bomb on Coolidge?

 
Anonymous
5 months ago
weapons arent allowed, just hand to hand

 
jroberts2010  [98 posts]
5 months ago
...or whatever kind of appendages these presidents had

 
 
madli  [5 posts]
5 months ago
fuck yeah, Billy all the way!

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
The two Bush's have to get in a fightfor the classical father vs. son fight to see who is superior.

 
 
holy_crepe  [12 posts]
5 months ago
While Bush was ins great shape relatively speaking, JFK surely was too, as he was in the Navy and famous for his heroism when he was on PT-109. I guess I'm just making excuses for why he should beat Bush, since I hated him so much. Oh well.

 
 
Ridiculous_Post  [1 post]
5 months ago
Should've listened to my sister when it came to Wilson.

 
 
laughterdude  [4 posts]
5 months ago
you mentioned that theodore "teddy" roosevelt was nicknamed after a bear. but, actuallt, teddy bears are named after him.

i am not kidding, that is not a hyperbole, joke or reversal based quip, the tedy bears are literally named after him

read it up
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teddy_bear

 
 
Takurai  [2 posts]
5 months ago
My favorite to win this is Unconditional Surrender Grant.

Obama's going out early, he's young, but not a fighter

 
 
Shade_of_Blue  [1 post]
5 months ago
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X58RPS665V0
As you can see in the above link, Lincoln will sweep the entire thing, even with his disadvantage of assassination. His normal vampiric opponents were far more agile and powerful than any mere human president. Plus, he's immortal now, he showed up with Henry at MLK's speech. My money rides with Honest Abe.

 
iburnmathbooks  [31 posts]
5 months ago
Dude. The end of that book was total bullshit. Abe was dead for like over a day before Henry Sturges supposedly turned him into a vampire. It was someone else who looked a lot like Lincoln that stopped the Nazis with Henry.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I want to see the two Bush's go against each other so badly. That would be hilarious. Nice work on these, made me lol several times!

I hate twitter ;_; sowry

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I was only right on 3 out of 8 of them. I was only right on Bush, Bush, and Roosevelt.

 
jroberts2010  [98 posts]
5 months ago
Hey, there's nothing wrong with a little Bush right? Because I can't go up to bat if there's no turf on the field ;D Yeaaaahh I'm sure that was awful for everyone

 
 
daveroolz  [2 posts]
5 months ago
dude i wanna see Washington VS Lincoln

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I guess Dubya does get that retard strength when he's angry.

 
 
palmtreebearer  [6 posts]
5 months ago
I've got Roosevelt and Obama in the final round with Roosevelt as the winner. The final 4, George W., Roosevelt, Jackson, and Obama.

 
palmtreebearer  [6 posts]
5 months ago
I just realized, I'm treating this like a serious thing. That is kind of sad really.

 
 
Animurphs  [12 posts]
5 months ago
Picks for next round:

1. Bush
2. Bush
3. Roosevelt
4. Reagan

 
 
beaverteeth92  [2 posts]
5 months ago
Harrison beats Bush
Cleveland beats Bush
Theodore Roosevelt clobbers Coolidge
Clinton beats Reagan


Other half of Round 1:

Carter beats Ford
Polk beats Hoover
Jackson massacres Madison
Adams beats Garfield
Van Buren beats Nixon (Van Buren was a fucking badass)
Grant beats Lincoln
Obama beats Johnson
Washington owns Adams

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Calvin Coolidge all the way!

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Hey, Matt, I don't want to be a douchebag, but Wilson was definitely NOT a war lover. He was a bookish idealist who wanted more than anything to have world peace. He really pushed hard to form the League of Nations, and even got a Nobel Peace Prize. And he only jumped into the war when Germany started threatening us more directly with U-boat warfare and the Zimmerman note

 
jroberts2010  [98 posts]
5 months ago
I think Matt believes that Ol' Willy was actually a deceitful prezdent who pushed the peaceful thing to cover the fact that the man wanted European blood more than anything. The failed League of Nations was just a ploy. Hahaha Willy you rascal you *shakes finger*

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Matt, you say that Clinton left office early to avoid impeachment, but I think you're thinking of Nixon. Clinton was impeached, but then acquitted by the Senate.

 
jkmacdonald  [14 posts]
5 months ago
Yeah that caught my attention too. Clinton didn't leave office. Had he left office Al Gore would've served a partial term as president before the 2000 election.

 
MattMelvin  "Head Robot"  [∞ posts]
5 months ago
You're right, good eye. Fixed!

 
 
lostbrane  [1 post]
5 months ago
Psh it's gonna be Nixon all the way(because he doesn't have to do the fighting himself....BECAUSE HE IS A CHEATER)

 
 
InvalidMusician  [9 posts]
5 months ago
Haha! We love you here in Holland matt ;) Just wanted to say that!
Oh, and Roosevelt is going to win in my opinion. Just hear how Dutch his name sounds!

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Whoa, Jackson wasn't a fighter? Are you nuts?
His nickname was "Old Hickory" because he *beat people*! And not just any people, congressmen. He beat congressmen!
And when a guy tried to shoot him, Jackson beat him down with his cane! How the hell could he loose a fight?
I call a rigged fight!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Jackson

 
 
thesmoothtalker  [1 post]
5 months ago
I was hoping to see some bush on bush.But not the presidents *sly smile + raised eyebrow*

 
 
thegoochinator  [1 post]
5 months ago
Just you watch.
It'll be Carter, Polk, Jackson, Q Adams, Nixon, Lincoln, Obama, and Washington.
Just you watch.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Damn i had my money on taft and i almost thougt that truman would get somewhere but damn Coolidge is an awsome fucking name

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
FDR???

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I'm being a jerk and posting anonymously :P

 
 
geeswild  [13 posts]
5 months ago
I'm going for Teddy Roosevelt. He once took a bullet in the chest before a speech. Checked to see if he had punctured a lung by seeing if he was coughing up blood. Then gave his speech without any medical treatment.

 
 
iburnmathbooks  [31 posts]
5 months ago
Reagan, Coolidge, Bush Senior, and Ben

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
LOL, you totally misspelled "ballot" as "ballet"
nice use of spell-check there.


oh and LOL my captcha is 45-caliber shampoo

 
 
KazikameIV  [1 post]
5 months ago
I personally think Washington is gonna kick the crap out of them. With all the terms he had not to mention being a war hero, its hard to think he isn't going to kill everyone else.

 
 
xeroxfm  [8 posts]
5 months ago
I have waited a long time to say that this is:

AWESOME.

Still think that Taft could roll over and make a kind of human wrecking ball, which would be epic. Until he hits a wall.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
3 words: George Fucking Washington.

No president is as badass as him. Glass jaw? Hell no, it's wood. Have you ever punched wood? It' hard. REALLY hard.

And, he defeated the British. Now there were other people involved, but who cares? George just gave his opponents splinters and musket balls to the face like an 18th century Rambo.

GW ALL DAY.

 
 
weberr13  [1 post]
5 months ago
"Clinton may have left office early to avoid impeachment,"

That was Nixon, nimrod. Clinton was impeached, but acquitted and served his entire term.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
It's gonna be Andrew Jackson vs. Theodore Roosevelt in the final round.

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
I call Grover Cleveland fighting himself at some point.

 
 
laughterdude  [4 posts]
5 months ago
oh, and for the next round i call the winners as Bush, Bush (mostly[entirely] because i want a bush vs bush) Roosevelt (because of reasons that should be obvious) and Reagan (took a shooting and lived)

 
 
Anonymous
5 months ago
Lincoln fought several duels. One with cow pies, and one with broadswords. Let me repeat that, the guy fought a duel with a BROADSWORD. And on top of that, he manipulated the rules so that the other guy had absolutely no chance because he was shorter. Lincoln all the way.

 
 
anarchitekt  [5 posts]
5 months ago
GO TEDDY GO, you classy mothereffer

 
 
CrackaPlease  [5 posts]
5 months ago
I am actually quite surprised that Benjamin Harrison beat Taft. Though taft would tire quickly, he would win instantly simply by his girth - rolling over, going to sleep, and suffocating Harrison, a minute individual.

Hayes' beard should have won.

I'm surprised Truman lost. This is the man known for telling North Korea and Kim Il Sung. "you better fucking stop or I'll nuke you. This is the man who won the 1948 election even when the newspaper printed that Dewey had won. HE JUST WONT ACCEPT DEFEAT! no way is he going to accept defeat from sone wussy like Calvin Coolidge - whom, by the way, had a shorter term, thus giving Truman the head start to win.

I'm sorry, Matt, but you called this incorrectly.

Coolidge was a pussy who is known for "looking presidential but being incompetent"

and these here people are right - Wilson wanted to do everything he could to avoid war, and Clinton fulfilled his entire two terms, Nixon was the one who resigned.

 
 
Jncarver11  [2 posts]
5 months ago
Did sweet, got 7/8! The only one i missed was Truman, ironic much?

 
 
Jncarver11  [2 posts]
5 months ago
For the next round i have Gerald Ford over Carter, he was in World War two and got offers to play professional football, win.
Polk over Hoover because Hoover was a humanitarian, and Polk started the Mexican american war and threatened Britain to a war.
Jackson over Madison, Jackson wins automatically because after an assassination attempt he attacked the assassin with his cane before his men could get there.
John Quincy Adams wins over Garfield because Garfield didn't even make it a year.
Nixon over Van Buren, because Nixon would cheat and bring a sword, owning Van Buren within the one minute given to him.
Grant over Lincoln, Lincoln was tall and scrawny while Grant was a tough military general. Lincoln was also assassinated while grant made it 8 years, further putting him behind in the fight.
Obama over Johnson, Johnson only gets two minutes, but Obama is much younger, in way better shape, and he's black.
Washington over Adams, their both really old, but Washington gets four minutes and he was a general fighting in the war, while Adams was negotiating treaties.

 
 
Bibbidybev  [11 posts]
4 months ago
teddy for the win bitches im not even from or in america but i am lovin president beatdown teddy ftw

 
 
ColoradoFunrise  [5 posts]
4 months ago
you should put the bush´s in a round together, that would be probably the high point of both of their lives. i doubt H. W. will make it, his name is to tell him apart from his son, its not neccesarliy a clever name. however he´s old.

 
 
Anonymous
4 months ago
I'm putting my money on Andrew Jackson. Dude was awesome.

 
 
Anonymous
2 months ago
Actually Teddy wasn't named after a bear; the bear was named after him. How cool is that, because I am NOT kidding.